OKRs Key Result Measurement: Navigating the Green Zero vs. Red 10 Conundrum

As an OKR practitioner, I frequently find myself peering into the future, ensuring that my clients set Key Results (KRs) that not only look good on paper but also align with the broader business goals. One common pitfall we strive to avoid is the “Green Zero vs. Red 10” scenario.

Understanding the Dilemma

Let’s consider a car dealership that sets a KR of selling ten high-end luxury cars in a quarter. Now, imagine two extreme scenarios:

Scenario 1: The Green Zero

• On paper: Zero sales, a clear failure.
• Reality: The dealer has received advance payments for 15 cars, to be invoiced in the following month. Is this a “Green Zero” or a hidden success?

Scenario 2: The Red 10

• On paper: Ten cars sold, a perfect result.
• Reality: To achieve this target, the sales manager offered excessive discounts, eroding the dealership’s profitability. Is this a true victory or a Pyrrhic one?

A Balanced Approach to KR Setting

To mitigate such risks, we recommend a balanced approach to the KR setting, considering the following:

1. Quality and Quantity: A mix of both ensures that not only the volume but also the quality of outcomes is prioritized.
2. Annual and 4-Monthly: Keep an eye on the long-term but let the short-term KRs drive the momentum, allowing for ongoing strategy adjustments rather than waiting until year-end
3. External and Internal: Measuring both external market performance and internal team efficiency offers a comprehensive perspective.
4. Health and Stretch: A combination of committed and challenging KRs keeps the team motivated and focused.
5. Financial and Non-Financial: Using monetary and non-monetary metrics together, e.g., employee engagement and cost rationalization, offers a well-rounded assessment that prevents organizational culture from becoming toxic.
6. Lead and Lag: Balancing leading indicators (consider organizational capital like knowledge, human capital, processes etc.) with lagging indicators (results) helps track progress and identify potential issues early on.

By carefully crafting KRs that incorporate these dimensions, organizations can avoid the pitfalls of the “Green Zero vs. Red 10” dilemma and drive sustainable, long-term success. What challenges have you faced in aligning KRs with long-term goals? Let’s set up a call to explore solutions together. Feel free to contact us at info@resconpartners.com.

***

The journey to effective Key Result measurement involves looking beyond immediate numbers and considering the broader business impact. By adopting a balanced and comprehensive approach, we can ensure that Key Results drive genuine business value and sustainable success.